Best Guitar Pickups – Buyer’s Guide & Reviews

All guitarists have a vague idea that guitar pickups are the things that generate sound on a guitar. However, for many, understanding stops there.

In this expert guide, we’re going to take a look at how they work, all the different types there are plus we’ll look at best guitar pickups for each particular kind of guitar.

At a Glance: Our Pick of the Best Guitar Pickups

Here’s what we’ll cover.

Buyer’s Guide – Key Considerations

Consider Your Sound

Before you dive in and buy a set, consider what sound you’re going for. Do you like heavy, precise guitars with a consistent dynamic, or are you more interested in getting a vintage twang, that you can control the volume of with your picking attack?

If your heart’s set on heaviness, a set of active high output ones will do the trick, however, if you’re looking for some responsive ones then old school, passive single-coils are the only way to go.

Know Your Gear

What kind of wood is your guitar made from? Mahogany and rosewood have a dark tone, so finding pickups to complement that will be a priority. Maple, ash, and alder have a brighter sound, so they might be best suited to pickups that hold on to the high-end frequencies.

Your volume knob affects your tone, too. 250K pots are warm, whereas 500K pots are bright.

Will it Fit?

Check that it’s physically possible to fit your pickup of choice into your guitar. Many are designed for particular types, such as Strats, Teles or Les Pauls. Others are more versatile, offering compatibility with multiple models.

If you have your mind set on fitting some humbuckers into your single-coil guitar but don’t know how you’re going to make it fit, there are now plenty of humbuckers shaped like single-coils to ease your pain. And there are single-coils available shaped like humbuckers.

Product Round-up & Mini Reviews – Best Guitar Pickup

DiMarzio DP419 Area 67

DiMarzio DP419 Area '67 Hum Canceling Strat Pickup Black

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON

The DiMarzio DP419 is a noiseless single-coil pickup. It has a high output, making it great for heavy players who want a lot of gain, while it’s still passive and allowing for dynamic control at the hands of the player. It also uses alnico magnets to produce a thick tone which is also crisp and bright.

It’s designed to fit Stratocasters and in particular the middle and neck positions. It can also work effectively in the bridge position, due to its high output.

The hum-canceling qualities of this mean that you have the benefits of humbuckers, with the compatibility and brightness of a single-coil.

This is very reasonably priced and comes in black so it will suit many Strat or Strat-style guitars. It will suit Stratocaster players who use their instrument to play a variety of genres and want the single-coil tone with protection from feedback.

It will be less suited to guitarists who would like a lower output, for an increased dynamic range.

PROS

  • Noiseless single-coil.
  • Compatible with all three positions.
  • Designed to fit in the popular Stratocaster.

CONS

  • Unsuitable for guitars other than Strats.
  • High output results in a reduced dynamic range.

Gibson’s ’57 Classic Plus

Gibson '57 Classic Plus Humbucker Pickup, Nickel

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON

The Gibson ’57 Classic Plus is a passive humbucker pickup that offers vintage tones with a few extra benefits.

It has a lot of coils, making it super silent and clear, and there’s also a high output which offers a silky smooth sound and great for precise, chunky lead playing.

The high output on the Gibson ’57 Classic Plus means that it deals exceptionally well with overdrive or distortion. It’s also fully wax potted to avoid unwanted microphonic noises.

It’s quite expensive, but it can work to make a less expensive guitar sound much better.

The Gibson ’57 Classic Plus is suited to a bridge pickup due to its high output and driving, chunky qualities. It will suit a Les Paul player who plays heavy music and requires something that will give their notes clarity and punch. It will be less suited to gentler players, who like to control their dynamics with their picking hand.

PROS

  • Thoroughly wax potted to reduce the risk of unwanted feedback.
  • Perfect bridge pickup companion to the Gibson ’57 Classic.
  • High output that is silky smooth.

CONS

  • Suitable for the bridge only.
  • Only really fits Gibson guitars.
  • High output might not suit those who want more dynamic range.

Seymour Duncan Antiquity

Seymour Duncan Antiquity Bridge Humbucker Pickup - Nickel

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON

These P90 pickups are passive single coil ones, available in bridge and neck variations. They use two calibrated alnico magnets with a custom coil wind to achieve a warm, vintage sound which is tonally similar to guitars in the 40s and 50s. The Seymour Duncan Antiquity P90s also have a vintage, worn look about them, available in either black or cream.

They cost roughly the same as the Gibson ’57 classic ones above, and they’re also well-suited to Gibsons. They’ll suit the guitarist who is looking for vintage tone and requires some control over their dynamics with their picking hand, but less suited to guitars like Strats, which would require some modification before fitting.

PROS

  • Uses two alnico magnets to produce a warm but sparkly midrange sound.
  • Replicates the original pickups of the 40s and 50s, giving you a classic tone.
  • Available in black or cream.

CONS

  • If you are looking for the twang of a single-coil, this won’t give you that.
  • Some guitars will need to be modified to fit p90s in.
  • Might be a bit too ‘retro’ looking for some people’s tastes.

Lace Sensor Blue-Silver-Red

Lace Sensor Blue-Silver-Red 3-Pack S-S-S Pickup Set Black

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON

The Lace Sensor Blue-Silver-Red set are perfect Strat pickups.

They’re color-coded red, silver and blue, with the red one being suited to the bridge position, the silver to the middle and the blue to the neck position. The red one has a higher output than the others, giving it a full, powerful sound. The silver one has a pronounced midrange as well as quite a high output, and the blue one has a lower output, giving it a warm tone that’s ideal for the neck position.

As they’re passive, you won’t need batteries, and they also use lower energy magnets than you usually find on pickups. This will lead to an increased sustain, so it will be perfect for those who want to emulate Dave Gilmour.

This is a reasonably priced set that will be perfect for Stratocaster players who require a variety of different sounds to play a varied selection of genres.

It will be less suited to players interested in achieving the heaviest possible sound, and the set will be unsuitable to players on guitars other than Strats.

PROS

  • They read a larger proportion of the string than others on this list while picking up less outside noise interference.
  • Lower energy magnets than normal ones, leading to an increase in sustain.
  • Designed to fit a Stratocaster.

CONS

  • Inappropriate for guitars that aren’t Strats.
  • The increase in sustain might not suit all genres.

Fender Vintage Noiseless Tele

Fender Vintage Noiseless Tele Pickups

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON

This collection of noiseless single coil passive pickups work great on a Telecaster and use enamel-coated alnico magnets to produce a vintage sound. They combine this with Fender’s ‘Noiseless’ technology to reduce the hum associated with vintage tones. They also include flush-mount pole pieces to ensure an even string response and come with installation hardware to make fitting them as easy as possible.

They’re reasonably priced and similar to the blue-silver-red set above and well suited to Telecaster players who love the vintage twang but also want a warm attack, an absence of hum and a non-aggressive midrange.

It will be less suited to heavy players looking for something with a high output and beefy tone.

PROS

  • Alcino magnets combined with Fender’s ‘Noiseless’ technology produces a vintage tone, without the hum.
  • Enamel-coated magnet encourages a warm, vintage tone.
  • Includes flush-mount pole pieces for an even string response

CONS

  • Won’t suit guitars that aren’t Tele’s.
  • You people might prefer less advanced technology if seeking a truly authentic vintage sound.

James Hetfield Humbucker

EMG JH James Hetfield Signature Guitar Pickup Set, Black Chrome

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON

The James Hetfield humbucker set from EMG is made for metal. Reasonably priced in a similar region to the Telecaster and Strat sets mentioned above, these are potted, versatile and easy to install. They can be fitted easily to a guitar that already has humbuckers, without even using a soldering iron. They’re active, giving them a higher output and a heaviness but still have the clarity and punch of passive ones.

True to their name, there is no humming feedback present, and they use steel pieces rather than bar magnets, which produces a tight attack and enables a clean low end.

The James Hetfield Humbucker set will be perfect for heavy metal guitarists who like to play loud. It will be less suited to guitarists looking for something to be gentle with, or to those who dislike the idea of relying on batteries.

PROS

  • Active response gives a higher output than passive, making them perfect for metal.
  • Solderless installation.
  • Humbuckers give out no unwanted feedback.

CONS

  • There’s a lack of dynamic range compared to single-coils.
  • Require a battery.

LR Baggs Anthem Tru-Mic

L.R. Baggs Anthem Acoustic Guitar Pickup and Microphone

CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON

The L R Baggs Anthem Tru-Mic is designed for use with an acoustic guitar. It blends a piezo with a mini microphone, which lets you fine-tune your EQ as the piezo brings out the higher frequencies and the microphone gives you a bassy warmth.

The microphone includes noise-canceling technology, to reduce any unwanted feedback and it can be fitted beneath the soundhole to keep your guitar’s original aesthetic.

It doesn’t come cheap but will be perfect for the professional, gigging musician who requires a high-quality amplification of their acoustic instrument. It will be less suited to acoustic guitarists on a budget and might benefit more from buying an electro-acoustic guitar for a similar price.

PROS

  • Volume and blend controls, as well as a battery indicator and a phase switch, give you excellent control over your output.
  • Works as a microphone and a piezo in a small plastic house, giving you tonal transparency and the ability to fine-tune your EQ.
  • Uses noise-canceling technology to eliminate feedback.

CONS

  • Might prove a bit tricky to install.
  • The bright tone it encourages might not suit all players.

Summary

If you use a Strat, your main choices are the DiMarzio DP419 and the Lace Sensor Blue-Silver-Red pickup set. The Dimarzio DP419 is a noiseless single-coil pickup, which is well-suited to the bridge, neck or middle position and offers the feedback-reduced benefits of a humbucker with all of the twang and brightness of a single-coil. Lace Sensor’s Blue-silver-red set has three different single-coils with slightly different output levels. They use low-energy magnets which lead to an increase in sustain. Both the Dimarzio DP419 and the Lace Sensor Blue-Silver-Red set are passive pickups.

If you play a Telecaster, the Fender Vintage Noiseless Tele is similar to the Strat’s DiMarzio DP419s in that it offers no-hum benefits with all of the brightness of a single-coil. This reasonably priced pickup set can turn your Tele from a noisy instrument to a bright, cutting and crisp Tele tone.

Gibson players have the choice of the Gibson ’57 Classic Plus or the Seymour Duncan Antiquity P90s. The Gibson ’57 Classic Plus pickups are humbuckers with a high output to offer a silky smooth, clear sound. The Antiquity P90s offer a more vintage tone and look, and have a lower output than the Classic Plus pickups, giving you more control over dynamics.

Metal players need look no further than the James Hetfield humbucker set. These pickups are active, so can play loudly and heavily while maintaining quality, and they’re also super-easy to install to metal guitars such as Jackson, Ibanez or Gibson guitars.

We only included one acoustic pickup here: the high-quality L R Baggs Anthem Tru-Mic. This combines a piezo pickup with a miniature microphone to achieve a rich, transparent and professional level amplification of an acoustic guitar.

Whatever style of music you play and on whichever guitar, we hope that this has helped you to find the right pickups for your genre and your gear.